| 1 | Prologue Original London Cast of Sister Act & Sheila Hancock | - |
| 2 | Take Me to Heaven Patina Miller, Debbie Kurup & Amy Booth Steel | - |
| 3 | Fabulous, Baby! Patina Miller, Debbie Kurup & Amy Booth Steel | - |
| 4 | Here Within These Walls Original London Cast of Sister Act & Sheila Hancock | - |
| 5 | How I Got the Calling Claire Greenaway, Julia Sutton, Katie Rowley Jones, Patina Miller & Original London Cast of Sister Act | - |
| 6 | When I Find My Baby Chris Jarman, Thomas Goodbridge, Nicolas Colicos & Ivan De Freitas | - |
| 7 | Do the Sacred Mass Claire Greenaway, Julia Sutton, Katie Rowley Jones, Patina Miller & Original London Cast of Sister Act | - |
| 8 | I Could Be That Guy Ako Mitchell | - |
| 9 | Raise Your Voice Claire Greenaway, Julia Sutton, Katie Rowley Jones, Patina Miller & Original London Cast of Sister Act | - |
| 10 | Take Me to Heaven (Reprise) Patina Miller, Claire Greenaway, Julia Sutton, Katie Rowley Jones & Original London Cast of Sister Act | - |
| 11 | Sunday Morning Fever Patina Miller, Sheila Hancock, Claire Greenaway, Julia Sutton, Katie Rowley Jones, Ian Lavender, Ako Mitchell & Original London Cast of Sister Act | - |
| 12 | Lady in the Long Black Dress Nicolas Colicos, Thomas Goodbridge & Ivan De Freitas | - |
| 13 | Bless Our Show Original London Cast of Sister Act & Patina Miller | - |
| 14 | Here Within These Walls (Reprise) Sheila Hancock | - |
| 15 | The Life I Never Led Katie Rowley Jones | - |
| 16 | Fabulous, Baby! (Reprise) Original London Cast of Sister Act & Patina Miller | - |
| 17 | Sister Act Patina Miller | - |
| 18 | The Life I Never Led (Reprise) Katie Rowley Jones | - |
| 19 | Sister Act (Reprise) [Reprise] Patina Miller, Sheila Hancock & Original London Cast of Sister Act | - |
| 20 | Spread the Love Around Original London Cast of Sister Act | - |