| 1 | Fly Me to the Moon (In Other Words) | - |
| 2 | When Sunny Gets Blue Johnny Mathis with Ray Conniff and His Orchestra | - |
| 3 | Chances Are | - |
| 4 | Wonderful! Wonderful! Johnny Mathis with Ray Conniff, His Orchestra & Chorus | - |
| 5 | It's Not for Me to Say | - |
| 6 | No Love (But Your Love) | - |
| 7 | The Twelfth of Never | - |
| 8 | Wild Is the Wind Johnny Mathis with Ray Ellis and His Orchestra | - |
| 9 | Teacher, Teacher | - |
| 10 | A Certain Smile | - |
| 11 | Misty | - |
| 12 | You Are Beautiful | - |
| 13 | Maria | - |
| 14 | My Funny Valentine | - |
| 15 | Small World | - |
| 16 | The Best of Everything | - |
| 17 | When I Fall in Love | - |
| 18 | Dancing on the Ceiling | - |
| 19 | I Wish I Were in Love Again | - |
| 20 | My Love for You | - |
| 21 | The Best Is Yet to Come | - |
| 22 | Stairway to the Stars | - |
| 23 | Gina | - |
| 24 | What Will My Mary Say | - |
| 25 | Beyond the Blue Horizon | - |
| 26 | No Strings | - |
| 27 | Bye Bye Barbara | - |
| 28 | On a Clear Day (You Can See Forever) | - |
| 29 | The Sweetheart Tree | - |
| 30 | Prelude to a Kiss | - |
| 31 | The Look of Love | - |
| 32 | A Time for Us | - |
| 33 | (Where Do I Begin) Love Story | - |
| 34 | What Are You Doing the Rest of Your Life? | - |
| 35 | The First Time Ever (I Saw Your Face) | - |
| 36 | I'm Coming Home | - |
| 37 | Life Is a Song Worth Singing | - |
| 38 | I'm Stone in Love With You | - |
| 39 | When Will I See You Again? | - |
| 40 | What I Did for Love | - |
| 41 | 99 Miles From L.A. | - |
| 42 | When a Child Is Born | - |
| 43 | You're All I Need to Get By Johnny Mathis feat. Deniece Williams | - |
| 44 | Too Much, Too Little, Too Late Johnny Mathis with Deniece Williams | - |
| 45 | Gone Gone Gone | - |
| 46 | Begin the Beguine | - |
| 47 | The Last Time I Felt Like This Johnny Mathis with Jane Olivor | - |
| 48 | Friends in Love Dionne Warwick and Johnny Mathis | - |
| 49 | Memory | - |
| 50 | Baia (No Baixa Do Sapateiro) Johnny Mathis & Henry Mancini | - |
| 51 | Let Your Heart Remember | - |
| 52 | Because You Loved Me | - |
| 53 | Un-Break My Heart | - |
| 54 | Brazil (Aquarela Do Brasil) | - |