| 1 | Overture Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 2 | Six Months Out of Every Year Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 3 | Scene: The Boyds’ Living Room Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 4 | Scene: The Boyds’ Front Porch Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 5 | Goodbye, Old Girl Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 6 | Blooper Ballet Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 7 | Scene: The Ball Field Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 8 | Heart Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 9 | Scene: The Locker Room Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 10 | Joe at Bat Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 11 | Shoeless Joe From Hannibal, Mo. Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 12 | Shoeless Joe (reprise) Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 13 | Scene: The Press Conference Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 14 | Scene: Applegate’s Apartment Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 15 | A Little Brains, a Little Talent Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 16 | Scene: The Boyds’ Kitchen Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 17 | A Man Doesn’t Know Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 18 | Scene: The Locker Room Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 19 | Whatever Lola Wants (Lola Gets) Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 20 | Scene: Act I Finale Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 21 | Whos Got the Pain? Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 22 | Scene: The Locker Room Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 23 | The Game Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 24 | Scene: The Boyds’ House Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 25 | Near to You Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 26 | Those Were the Good Old Days Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 27 | The Trial Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 28 | Scene: Limbo Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 29 | Two Lost Souls Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 30 | Scene: The Bottom of the Ninth Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
| 31 | A Man Doesn’t Know (reprise) Richard Adler & Jerry Ross | - |
