| 1 | Prelude Caissie Levy, Jack Wolfe | - |
| 2 | Just Another Day | - |
| 3 | Everything Else Eleanor Worthington-Cox | - |
| 4 | Who's Crazy / My Psychopharmacologist and I | - |
| 5 | Perfect for You Eleanor Worthington-Cox, Jack Ofrecio | - |
| 6 | I Miss the Mountains Caissie Levy | - |
| 7 | It's Gonna Be Good | - |
| 8 | He's Not Here Jamie Parker | - |
| 9 | You Don't Know Caissie Levy | - |
| 10 | I Am the One Jamie Parker, Jack Wolfe, Caissie Levy | - |
| 11 | Superboy and the Invisible Girl Eleanor Worthington-Cox, Jack Wolfe, Caissie Levy | - |
| 12 | I'm Alive Jack Wolfe | - |
| 13 | Make Up Your Mind / Catch Me I'm Falling | - |
| 14 | I Dreamed a Dance Caissie Levy, Jack Wolfe | - |
| 15 | There's a World Jack Wolfe | - |
| 16 | I've Been Jamie Parker | - |
| 17 | Didn't I See This Movie? Caissie Levy | - |
| 18 | A Light in the Dark Jamie Parker, Caissie Levy | - |
| 19 | Entr'acte Tom Kitt | - |
| 20 | Wish I Were Here | - |
| 21 | Song of Forgetting Caissie Levy, Jamie Parker & Eleanor Worthington-Cox | - |
| 22 | Hey #1 Eleanor Worthington-Cox, Jack Ofrecio | - |
| 23 | Seconds and Years Trevor Dion Nicholas, Jamie Parker, Caissie Levy | - |
| 24 | Better Than Before Caissie Levy, Jamie Parker, Eleanor Worthington-Cox, Trevor Dion Nicholas | - |
| 25 | Aftershocks Jack Wolfe | - |
| 26 | Hey #2 Eleanor Worthington-Cox, Jack Ofrecio | - |
| 27 | You Don't Know (reprise) Caissie Levy, Trevor Dion Nicholas | - |
| 28 | How Could I Ever Forget? Caissie Levy, Jamie Parker | - |
| 29 | It's Gonna Be Good (Reprise) Jamie Parker, Caissie Levy | - |
| 30 | Why Stay? / A Promise Caissie Levy, Eleanor Worthington-Cox, Jamie Parker, Jack Ofrecio | - |
| 31 | I'm Alive (reprise) Jack Wolfe | - |
| 32 | The Break Caissie Levy | - |
| 33 | Make Up Your Mind / Catch Me I'm Falling (reprise) Caissie Levy, Jack Wolfe, Trevor Dion Nicholas | - |
| 34 | Maybe (Next to Normal) Caissie Levy, Eleanor Worthington-Cox | - |
| 35 | Hey #3 / Perfect for You (reprise) Eleanor Worthington-Cox, Jack Ofrecio | - |
| 36 | So Anyway Caissie Levy | - |
| 37 | I Am the One (reprise) Jamie Parker, Jack Wolfe | - |
| 38 | Light | - |