Injured in a serious car crash, supermodel Shannon McNab's world is rocked by a prominent scar on her left cheek. Shaken by this "imperfection," Shannon's fiance abandons her. When an old high school friend drags Shannon to a church singles group, she meets Judd Manning, a sweet, down-to-earth schoolteacher who makes her laugh and see what's most important in life. As they grow closer to each other and the Lord, a romantic attraction builds. But when Shannon's scar fades, the lure of her glamorous old life proves too strong to resist. Judd has always known that being in a relationship with Shannon is like trying to catch a star with his bare hands. Is it possible for a jet-setting supermodel and a home-loving schoolteacher to find common ground?