Skip to main content

Results

They’re Only Chasing Safety
A #1

They’re Only Chasing Safety

Underoath

2004·5 grades
The Eye of Every Storm
A #2

The Eye of Every Storm

Neurosis

2004·4 grades
MM..FOOD
A #3

MM..FOOD

MF DOOM

2004·5 grades
Panopticon
A- #4

Panopticon

Isis

2004·5 grades
Of Malice and the Magnum Heart
A- #5

Of Malice and the Magnum Heart

Misery Signals

2004·3 grades
Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge
A- #6

Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge

My Chemical Romance

2004·5 grades
The End of Heartache
A- #7

The End of Heartache

Killswitch Engage

2004·3 grades
The College Dropout
A- #8

The College Dropout

Ye

2004·3 grades
I Am Hollywood
A- #9

I Am Hollywood

He Is Legend

2004·4 grades
Leviathan
A- #10

Leviathan

Mastodon

2004·5 grades
Ashes of the Wake
A- #11

Ashes of the Wake

Lamb of God

2004·5 grades
You Fail Me
A- #12

You Fail Me

Converge

2004·5 grades
Vol. 3: (The Subliminal Verses)
A- #13

Vol. 3: (The Subliminal Verses)

Slipknot

2004·4 grades
This Type of Thinking (Could Do Us In)
A- #14

This Type of Thinking (Could Do Us In)

Chevelle

2004·3 grades
“Watch Out!”
A- #15

“Watch Out!”

Alexisonfire

2004·3 grades
Hot Fuss
A- #16

Hot Fuss

The Killers

2004·4 grades
Terrifyer
A- #17

Terrifyer

Pig Destroyer

2004·4 grades
Funeral
A- #18

Funeral

Arcade Fire

2004·3 grades
American Idiot
B+ #19

American Idiot

Green Day

2004·3 grades
Good News for People Who Love Bad News
B+ #20

Good News for People Who Love Bad News

Modest Mouse

2004·3 grades
We Are Not Alone
B+ #21

We Are Not Alone

Breaking Benjamin

2004·4 grades
The System Has Failed
B+ #22

The System Has Failed

Megadeth

2004·3 grades
Encore
B #23

Encore

Eminem

2004·3 grades