Skip to main content
Electric Sheep

Share Your Music Hot Takes

By Electric Sheep
September 15, 202611 items160 views

Exactly what the title says. Bring out the genuine hot takes - ragebait is too easy.

Cheers if you like this post — or let them know you're salty about it. Tap a number to see who reacted.22 comments
All the Right Reasons1
All the Right Reasons
Nickelback · 2005
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeB+ CommunityB+
I think we've come full circle where this isn't a hot take anymore, but for at least a decade it was. This is genuinely a good album along Silver Side Up.
Maggot Brain2
Maggot Brain
Funkadelic · 1971
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeA+ CommunityA+
The song Maggot Brain is the greatest guitar solo of all time
Ride the Lightning3
Ride the Lightning
Metallica · 1984
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeA+ CommunityA+
This > Master of Puppets
How I Got Over4
How I Got Over
The Roots · 2010
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeA CommunityA
This is the best Roots album
Cheat Codes5
Cheat Codes
Black Thought · 2022
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeA CommunityA
This is better than any Roots album
After Hours6
After Hours
The Weeknd · 2020
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeA+ CommunityA
This is the best pop album in the last 20 years, probably
Leviathan7
Leviathan
Mastodon · 2004
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeB+ CommunityA-
This is one of the most overrated albums of its era among its peers
White Pony8
White Pony
Deftones · 2000
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeA CommunityA
This isn't their best album, despite being their most innovative
Disclaimer9
Disclaimer
Seether · 2002
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeA- CommunityA-
This is criminally underrated
None So Vile10
None So Vile
Cryptopsy · 1996
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeB+ CommunityA-
Overrated
Nespithe11
Nespithe
Demilich · 1993
Electric SheepElectric Sheep's gradeB+ CommunityA
Overrated (2)

Comments22

or to join the conversation

Caleb
CalebGold badge · Topped the community leaderboard for October 2026September 19, 2026 at 6:01 AM

I cannot stand Falling in Reverse

kip
kipSeptember 18, 2026 at 1:53 PM

The Mars Volta is probably the most overrated band I can think of

combustion07
combustion07Silver badge · Graded works released in 10 different decadesSeptember 18, 2026 at 7:18 AM

Also B+ Demilich rating should be included as a hot take lol

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 18, 2026 at 11:57 AM

Good point

Inveigh
InveighSeptember 17, 2026 at 2:36 AM

You're right about 9, so I'll forgive your steaming hot dump of a take on 7.

PurelyHated305
PurelyHated305September 17, 2026 at 2:37 AM

I have personally enjoyed most of what Seether has released.

PurelyHated305
PurelyHated305September 17, 2026 at 2:28 AM

Metalcore peaked in 2009 and it's been struggling to get back to that ever since.

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 17, 2026 at 2:32 AM

not sure that's a hot take tbh

PurelyHated305
PurelyHated305September 17, 2026 at 2:34 AM

Not amongst us, but I can assure you it's pretty hot if you're in your early 20s.

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 17, 2026 at 2:36 AM
GIF
PurelyHated305
PurelyHated305September 17, 2026 at 2:40 AM

If you are, then I'm

Adam Milton
Adam MiltonSilver badge · Used every grade at least once, A+ through FSeptember 17, 2026 at 2:11 AMedited

This is a wonderful youtube video about Nickleback and how they became so hated. youtu.be/GFC4OFWIPtw?si=A4uQS9OhsqR9TXhT EDIT: I'm not working harder than this to share the link.

combustion07
combustion07Silver badge · Graded works released in 10 different decadesSeptember 16, 2026 at 3:55 AM

Blood Mountain is the best Mastodon followed by Remission. Early ICP and Twiztid is actually not terrible and often has really cool production. Esoteric Warfare is the best Mayhem album and pretty much perfect.

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 16, 2026 at 4:16 AM

Remission was my favorite Mastodon album from the beginning. The new one might surpass it, though.

combustion07
combustion07Silver badge · Graded works released in 10 different decadesSeptember 18, 2026 at 7:17 AM

Verified that it in fact rules via work jam. The tripped out last half of The Three Fates is amazing, The Vanishing and In the Ruins stood out too. Definitely got the Floyd vibes

alkemest
alkemestBronze badge · Graded 100+ Black Metal albumsSeptember 19, 2026 at 5:28 AM

ICP aren't awful agreed and Esoteric Warfare does rip! I don't think it beats DMDS for me but it's fighting for second with Chimera.

MonkeyDPoopy
MonkeyDPoopyPlatinum badge · Graded more Manga books than anyone on the siteSeptember 15, 2026 at 6:24 PMedited

Asking Alexandria is one of the most overrated Metalcore bands of all time.

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 15, 2026 at 6:26 PM

yeah they suck. along with We Came as Romans

Kirkletonn
KirkletonnBronze badge · Graded 100+ Horror moviesSeptember 15, 2026 at 6:18 PM

I like After Hours

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 15, 2026 at 5:52 PM

I don't have many hot takes. I'll add them as I think of them