Skip to main content
Kirkletonn

I need scary movie suggestions

By Kirkletonn
September 11, 20267 items74 views

So I wanted to make this list as a somewhat community curated list for some scary movies. Mainly because, I am getting my wife slowly into horror. I took her to see IT beack when we first started dating and she was terrified after and never watched a horror movie with me since. However the last couple years I have gotten her to watch a couple of horror movies that she actually enjoyed so I am looking for help on suggestions of movies to watch with her for Halloween this year! Below is the movies I planned on watching this year with her already. As a kind of gauge for suggestions, she loved Sinners and Backrooms but she did not like IT or Obsession.

Cheers if you like this post — or let them know you're salty about it. Tap a number to see who reacted.12 comments
Sinners1
Sinners
Ryan Coogler · 2025
KirkletonnKirkletonn's gradeA CommunityA-
Rewatch
Backrooms2
Backrooms
Kane Parsons · 2026
KirkletonnKirkletonn's gradeB CommunityB-
Rewatch
Godzilla Minus One3
Godzilla Minus One
Takashi Yamazaki · 2023
KirkletonnKirkletonn's gradeA+ CommunityA-
I know it isn't really a horror movie but I want an excuse to rewatch
Nope4
Nope
Jordan Peele · 2022
KirkletonnKirkletonn's gradeA- CommunityB+
First for her
World War Z5
World War Z
Marc Forster · 2013
KirkletonnKirkletonn's gradeB CommunityB
First for her
Train to Busan6
Train to Busan
Yeon Sang-ho · 2016
KirkletonnKirkletonn's gradeA CommunityA
First for her
Iron Lung7
Iron Lung
Mark Fischbach · 2026
KirkletonnKirkletonn's gradeB- CommunityC
First for her

Comments12

or to join the conversation

combustion07
combustion07Silver badge · Graded works released in 10 different decadesSeptember 11, 2026 at 7:24 PM

Seconding Pontypool. The Clovehitch Killer and The House That Jack Built for more good serial killer stuff. I Saw the Devil is a masterful revenge movie if she doesn’t mind darker stuff. Poltergeist for classic stuff. Murder Party for a horror/comedy and Green Room, same director totally different vibes

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 11, 2026 at 7:53 PM

I would not recommend The House That Jack Built for someone new to horror lol

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 11, 2026 at 7:53 PM

Green Room is one of my favorites though

combustion07
combustion07Silver badge · Graded works released in 10 different decadesSeptember 11, 2026 at 7:57 PM

lol yeah that and I Saw the Devil might both be a bit of a stretch. I feel like I nailed it with Murder Party though it even takes place on Halloween! Maybe replace House that Jack Built with Housebound. Pretty light one from New Zealand with an interesting plot

kenzo
kenzoPlatinum badge · Graded more War books than anyone on the siteSeptember 11, 2026 at 5:23 PM

To follow up X, I really enjoyed Pearl the most. I second Jennifer's Body, but I would also add The Silence of the Lambs as a good starter. The Scream franchise also might be on the easier side imo. If you want something absolutely unserious and ridiculous (and frankly a bad movie that's kinda playing on the fact that it's a bad movie) Spree.

Kirkletonn
KirkletonnBronze badge · Graded 100+ Horror moviesSeptember 11, 2026 at 5:26 PM

Scream was one I thought of awhile ago but totally forgot so thank you for the reminder! I for sure think she can handle that. The Silence of the Lambs should also be another great pick because she loved Zodiac and they got the same vibe imo

Adam Milton
Adam MiltonSilver badge · Used every grade at least once, A+ through FSeptember 11, 2026 at 8:32 PM

I second The Silence of the Lambs . It is one of the best paced films I have ever seen.

Caleb
CalebGold badge · Topped the community leaderboard for October 2026September 11, 2026 at 5:06 PM

The Thing An American Werewolf in London The Lost Boys

Kirkletonn
KirkletonnBronze badge · Graded 100+ Horror moviesSeptember 11, 2026 at 5:16 PM

The Thing would be too freaky for the wife unfortunately. Classic tho

Caleb
CalebGold badge · Topped the community leaderboard for October 2026September 11, 2026 at 5:23 PM

Ok, swap that with Tremors

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 11, 2026 at 2:35 PM

Pontypool X Jennifer's Body

Caleb
CalebGold badge · Topped the community leaderboard for October 2026September 11, 2026 at 5:08 PM

I second X such an awesome movie