Skip to main content
Kirkletonn

I need scary movie suggestions

By Kirkletonn· September 11, 2026 · 7 items ·43 views

So I wanted to make this list as a somewhat community curated list for some scary movies. Mainly because, I am getting my wife slowly into horror. I took her to see IT beack when we first started dating and she was terrified after and never watched a horror movie with me since. However the last couple years I have gotten her to watch a couple of horror movies that she actually enjoyed so I am looking for help on suggestions of movies to watch with her for Halloween this year! Below is the movies I planned on watching this year with her already. As a kind of gauge for suggestions, she loved Sinners and Backrooms but she did not like IT or Obsession.

3

Comments12

to leave a comment

combustion07
combustion07

Seconding Pontypool.

The Clovehitch Killer and
The House That Jack Built
for more good serial killer stuff.
I Saw the Devil
is a masterful revenge movie if she doesn’t mind darker stuff.
Poltergeist
for classic stuff.
Murder Party
for a horror/comedy and
Green Room
, same director totally different vibes

1
Electric Sheep
Electric Sheep

I would not recommend

The House That Jack Built for someone new to horror lol

Replying to @electricsheep
combustion07
combustion07

lol yeah that and I Saw the Devil might both be a bit of a stretch. I feel like I nailed it with Murder Party though it even takes place on Halloween! Maybe replace House that Jack Built with

Housebound. Pretty light one from New Zealand with an interesting plot

1
Electric Sheep
Electric Sheep

Green Room is one of my favorites though

kenzo
kenzo

To follow up

X, I really enjoyed
Pearl
the most. I second
Jennifer's Body
, but I would also add
The Silence of the Lambs
as a good starter. The
Scream
franchise also might be on the easier side imo. If you want something absolutely unserious and ridiculous (and frankly a bad movie that's kinda playing on the fact that it's a bad movie)
Spree
.

2
Kirkletonn
Kirkletonn

Scream was one I thought of awhile ago but totally forgot so thank you for the reminder! I for sure think she can handle that.
The Silence of the Lambs
should also be another great pick because she loved
Zodiac
and they got the same vibe imo

3
Replying to @Kirkletonn
Adam Milton
Adam Milton

I second

The Silence of the Lambs . It is one of the best paced films I have ever seen.

Caleb
Caleb

The Thing
An American Werewolf in London
The Lost Boys

1
Kirkletonn
Kirkletonn

The Thing would be too freaky for the wife unfortunately. Classic tho

Replying to @Kirkletonn
Caleb
Caleb

Ok, swap that with

Tremors

1
Electric Sheep
Electric Sheep

Pontypool
X
Jennifer's Body

2
Caleb
Caleb

I second

X such an awesome movie