Skip to main content

What is your favorite Silent Hill game?

Silent Hill: Townfall is scheduled to release in one week!

Caleb Caleb
September 17, 20269 comments
  1. Silent Hill 21st
    Silent Hill 2 (Original or remake)
    60% · 3 votes
  2. Silent Hill2nd
    Silent Hill
    20% · 1 vote
  3. Silent Hill f2nd
    Silent Hill f
    20% · 1 vote
Silent Hill 2
Silent Hill 2 (Original or remake)
Silent Hill 2
60% · 3 votes
Silent Hill
Silent Hill
1999 · Team Silent
20% · 1 vote
Silent Hill f
Silent Hill f
2025 · NeoBards Entertainment
20% · 1 vote

5 people have voted

or

Comments9

or to join the conversation

Kirkletonn
KirkletonnBronze badge · Graded 100+ Horror moviesSeptember 18, 2026 at 12:39 PM
Silent Hill fSilent Hill f

I know silent hill 2 is the most iconic and memorable of the franchise, but I gotta give flowers to Silent Hill f , artistically and style wise its the best one we have ever gotten. It took big leaps that I felt paid off that felt true to the silent hill origins but also had its own identity throughout

combustion07
combustion07Silver badge · Graded works released in 10 different decadesSeptember 17, 2026 at 7:20 PM
Silent HillSilent Hill

From what I remember The Room was pretty cool too. Haven’t played it in forever though and remember it getting trashed but I liked it

Caleb
CalebGold badge · Topped the community leaderboard for October 2026September 17, 2026 at 8:23 PM
Silent Hill 2Silent Hill 2 (Original or remake)

The Room is actually a solid game! I enjoyed it. When I streamed it on twitch a lot of people said it was their favorite SH game which was surprising to me

combustion07
combustion07Silver badge · Graded works released in 10 different decadesSeptember 17, 2026 at 11:06 PM
Silent HillSilent Hill

If it wasn’t so pricey I’d definitely grab a ps2 copy to play it again

Caleb
CalebGold badge · Topped the community leaderboard for October 2026September 18, 2026 at 3:29 AM
Silent Hill 2Silent Hill 2 (Original or remake)

Yeah the prices are insane. I bought most of them pre covid when I was heavy into collecting old games, and now everything is so expensive. My collection has definitely slowed down a lot since the pandemic

combustion07
combustion07Silver badge · Graded works released in 10 different decadesSeptember 17, 2026 at 7:17 PM
Silent HillSilent Hill

Voted the OG for the nostalgia. 2 is probably a little better though. I went back and replayed the first one right after I got out of high school and I took a break to smoke a cig and it was snowing outside and there was a siren going off that sounded eerily similar to the one in the game lol

Electric Sheep
Electric SheepPlatinum badge · Graded more Post-Rock albums than anyone on the siteSeptember 17, 2026 at 5:38 PM

I've never played a Silent Hill game

GIF
Caleb
CalebGold badge · Topped the community leaderboard for October 2026September 17, 2026 at 6:22 PM
Silent Hill 2Silent Hill 2 (Original or remake)
GIF
kenzo
kenzoPlatinum badge · Graded more War books than anyone on the siteSeptember 17, 2026 at 6:50 PM
Silent Hill 2Silent Hill 2 (Original or remake)
GIF